Old San Juan Eats: A Guide to the Best Restaurants in the City

Updated 11/26/2023

From charming pizzerias serving up delectable thin-crust to vibrant Mexican and Caribbean restaurants offering authentic flavors, this blog will guide you through some of the top dining destinations of Old San Juan!

Pirilo

When it comes to satisfying your pizza cravings, Pirilo is the place to be. This charming pizzeria is known for its delectable thin-crust pizzas, if you’re a fan of classic Margherita or prefer more adventurous toppings like prosciutto and arugula, they have it all. Their dough is made fresh daily, and they source their ingredients locally.

With its inviting ambiance, incredible pizza selection, and top-notch service, this pizzeria is a slice of heaven you won’t want to miss.

Patio del Nispero

Located in Hotel El Convento, Patio del Nispero showcases the richness of the island’s culinary heritage through mouthwatering seafood dishes like ceviche and grilled octopus to hearty mofongo and tender roasted pork. They have a beautiful open-air courtyard, creating an intimate setting to enjoy your meal.

If you’re a wine enthusiast, they have an impressive selection of Albarino wines for you to try!

Bacaro

Step into the world of Venetian cuisine at Bacaro with an extensive menu that pays homage to the flavors of Italy! No visit to Bacaro would be complete without experiencing its high-quality seafood and meat offerings. From tender grilled octopus to succulent roasted lamb, the main courses at Bacaro are carefully prepared to highlight the natural flavors of the ingredients.

For a taste of Venice in the heart of Old San Juan, Bacaro is the culinary destination to visit.

Istanbul Restaurant

Istanbul Restaurant offers a unique dining experience that combines traditional Turkish recipes with a touch of Caribbean flair. The restaurant’s cozy seating arrangements create the perfect setting for a memorable meal.

The menu is a true culinary journey through the diverse regions of Turkey. Start with a selection of mezze, including classics like hummus, baba ganoush, and stuffed grape leaves. Don’t miss the opportunity to try their signature dish, the lamb shank braised to perfection and served with a side of aromatic couscous.

They source high-quality ingredients and incorporate local flavors into their dishes, creating a fusion of Turkish and Caribbean influences. This exciting twist to traditional Turkish recipes creates a dining experience that is both familiar and delightfully unexpected.

La Madre

For a mouthwatering Mexican and Caribbean dining experience look no further than La Madre. This vibrant restaurant is known for its authentic flavors, colorful decor, and lively atmosphere.

They offer yummy appetizers like guacamole and fresh salsa with warm tortilla chips. Try a variety of ceviche and tostadas bursting with bold flavors like lime, cilantro, and fresh seafood. Indulge in flavorful tacos filled with grilled meats, crispy Baja-style fish, or hearty vegetarian options. To complement your meal, La Madre features an impressive selection of tequilas and mezcal.

Check out their socials to catch live music nights!

Aliado

Discover the plant-based paradise of Aliado in Old San Juan. From the delightful arancini and perfectly balanced raviolo to the refreshing cocktails, this restaurant is a haven for plant-based food enthusiasts.

With a cozy and inviting atmosphere, Aliado provides a warm and memorable dining experience. Whether you’re a vegan or looking to experiment, Aliado’s innovative and delicious dishes are sure to impress your taste buds and leave you wanting more.

Salty Senorita

Salty Senorita is a Mexican Seafood fusion restaurant in Old San Juan that has gained popularity for its exceptional service, delectable food, and refreshing drinks. From the tempting appetizers like chips and salsa to the mouthwatering tacos and ceviche, their menu has many delicious options to enjoy.

Salty Senorita combines the rich and vibrant flavors of Mexican cuisine with the freshest and finest seafood PR has to offer. Make sure to visit their website for more information and plan your next meal!

More Articles for You

Nonprofits To Support In Old San Juan

We are highlighting some of the incredible nonprofits you can support based in Old San Juan. These organizations are dedicated …

Traditional Holiday Food & Drink In Old San Juan

What better way to celebrate this holiday season than indulging in the traditional, authentic  holiday flavors of Puerto Rico. Get …

— Featured —

5 Best Tours In Old San Juan

If you’re planning a visit to Old San Juan, be sure to make the most of your time with the …

— Featured —

Breakfast Spots In Old San Juan

If you’re looking for a spot to enjoy an early meal in Old San Juan you’re in the right place. …

— Featured —

Things To Do In Old San Juan: Christmas Edition

The holiday season in Old San Juan is filled with an array of exciting events, festive markets, and traditions. This …

— Featured —

A Guide To La Fortaleza In Old San Juan

La Fortaleza is a historic fortress and the official residence of the Governor of Puerto Rico.  In this comprehensive guide, …

— Featured —

Never Miss Out

Sign up for our newsletter to learn about events, new openings and other exciting things at Old San Juan Escape.